Lockport Union-Sun & Journal — NIAGARA FALLS — Police made a gruesome discovery Sunday in their investigation in the death of Loretta Gates.
Just before noon, patrol officers responded to Duck Island in Hyde Park where a passerby had noticed a bag floating in the lake and pulled it to shore. Inside the bag were human remains.
In a statement released to the news media on Sunday evening, Cataract City cops said, "The remains have been positively identified as belonging to homicide victim Loretta Jo Gates."
Sources close to the case have indicated that Gates' head and an arm were inside the bag. Investigators did not comment on what the "human remains" in the bag were.
Authorities in Niagara Falls, Ont., are also attempting to confirm that an arm and leg that were recovered in the whirlpool rapids on Friday afternoon also came from Gates' body. Those remains were spotted by a fisherman and retrieved by Niagara Regional Police.
A source with knowledge of the case tells Greater Niagara Newspapers that the discovery of body parts in the Falls may be a break in the case. The source said it would likely mean that Gates was murdered in the Falls and that the dismembered parts of her body were then disposed of at locations around the city.
Authorities confirmed on Friday that DNA testing showed that the torso of a woman, found floating in the lower Niagara River on Aug. 29, was the missing Falls mother of three. Just after noon Friday, investigators were notified that a DNA sample from Gates matched DNA recovered by Canadian law enforcement agencies from the torso.
At that time, investigators said they were trying to determine where Gates may have been killed. They said that locating a "crime scene" might yield key forensic evidence that would assist in the investigation.
"We don't know where she died, we're looking for a crime scene because hopefully there will be some evidence there,' the source said.