subscribesubscriber servicescontact usabout ussite mapBuy a Classified
Sun, Nov 08 2009 

Published: June 11, 2008 12:56 am    print this story  

LAKE LEVELS: Shoreline property owners vent to IJC

By Bill Wolcott
E-mail Bill

Lockport Union-Sun & Journal

NEWFANE International Joint Commission leaders from Canada and the United States on the got an earful from a packed crowd at the Olcott Firehall on Tuesday.

Shoreline residents, who are concerned about their eroding property on Lake Ontario, wondered if their words would sink in.

“It’s the same as it always has been,” said Mary Lou Fisher of Somerset, who got emotional when she spoke. “They listen to us. They smile at us. They send us home, and we lose our walls and our land and our property.”

Gary Halbach of Somerset was not swayed at proceedings that last two hours. “I got the same conclusion that I came with,” he said. “They’re going to ram this through no matter what, regardless of the homeowners.

“I saw it happen with the coal power plant in Somerset. Nobody wanted that, and they rammed it through. Plan B is already a done deal. They put it under the disguise as being environmental. That’s not what it’s about. It’s about the power that Canada is taking.”

Irene B. Brooks, chairman of the U.S. Section, and Herb Gray, the chair of the Canadian Section, made assurances that a decision has not been made on the a plan.

“I find the public very wise, and we put a lot of weight behind what the public comment is,” she said. “We take it all to heart and listen very carefully.”

There are still eight more citizen sites to be visited through July 11.

Gray noted how complicated the issue gets. There are not only interests on Lake Ontario, but down the St. Lawrence River to Montreal and to the Atlantic Ocean.

“We have a mandate from the two national governments,” Gray said. “It’s our duty to consider seriously and impartially. What’s presented to us taken into account all the various interests involved ... We have to look at all the interests. It can be controversial.”

Plan B-plus, favored by environmentalists, came under fire from south shore property owners. Plan 2007 got more support, but several speakers were upset that they did not have a chance to study the 146-page final report and the 262-page annexes.

Many speakers, who were each given five minutes to speak, blasted the state Department of Environmental Conservation as being an enemy of the lake shore residents.

Letters from Assemblywoman Francine Delmonte, D-Niagara Falls, and state Sen. George Maziarz, R-Newfane, concurred with the criticism of the DEC.

“It stuns me that a $20 million study yielded inconclusive results regarding Plan B-plus success in protecting wetlands,” Delmonte stated. “The IJC should pursue alternative Plan 2007...”

David Klein of the Nature Conservancy was one of the few speakers who supported Plan B-plus, and he was not warmly received. He argued to “work with the natural cycles of Lake Ontario. Bring back the natural cycles ... The shoreline will repair themselves.”

He was briefly interrupted and told to “put a gag in it,” when his five minutes were up.

Many speakers told of serious erosion of their lake shore properties and complained of paying taxes on land that is now under water.

Supervisor Tim Horanburg told of sandbagging in 1973. “I see those days coming again,” he said. “Getting a permit (from DEC) is nearly impossible.”

Fisherman told of the threat to charter service in Wilson. The owner of the Wilson Boat House told of the flooding in his banquet room.

A woman said, “Let my water go.” That is, let the St. Lawrence River water flow instead of backing it up at the dam.

Environmentalists urged respect for all life on the lake and to restore wetland diversity, and claimed a 2,000 signers of a petition for Plan B-plus.

Tony McKenna, who has represented the area during the five years of the study, feels that Plan B-plus does not treat all equally. Plan 2007 would be an improvement. He criticized the environmental data and warned against using questionable science to support Plan B. McKenna said the DEC is adversarial.

A Wilson man who grew up on the lake said he once had 35 feet of beach. Now he has 3 feet of water on the breakwall.

There was some cynicism regarding the IJC. “When you walk away, who will protect us,” Kathy O’Keefe of Wilson said.

Town Attorney James Sansone noted the importance of tourism at Olcott Beach and asked the IJC to consider the economic impact.

“We are trusting you to make the proper decision,” he said. “It will affect many people.”

The first IJC forum was in near Niagara Falls, Ontario. The next is in Rochester.

There is a question of how much can be controlled. “Experts agree there’s only so much you can do to control mother nature,” Gray said. “The water going through the dams can help moderate the highs and overcome lows.”

print this story  



autoconx
Premier Guide
Find a business

Walking Fingers
Maps, Menus, Store hours, Coupons, and more...
Premier Guide
Featured Jobs

Service Greeter
Service greeter wanted, PT entry level. Looking for someone with strong customer service skills to work in our fast grow...>MORE


INSURANCE - CSR with Personal Lines exp., for Lockport area. $25,000 salary. 433-7504...>MORE

Customer Service
Customer Service
CARPET CLEANING
$400-$600/week
Our customers have cleaning fever. Openings for men & wom
...>MORE

Nursing
NURSING. RN's. Up to $7500 Sign on Bonus. Thinking of a change? Consider Mount St. Mary's Hospital. Various positions av...>MORE

Job Fair
HUMAN SERVICES
JOB FAIR
For COMMUNITY MISSIONS

Program Locations/Job Opportunities
working w/c
...>MORE

WAIT STAFF
WaitSTAFF P/T 11am -2pm or 3:15-6:45pm. Will train. Apply Amberleigh Retirement, 2330 Maple near Transit. ...>MORE


CARPENTER: Framing, 3-5 years exp. $11-15/hr DOE. Transportation necessary. 716-689-6829...>MORE

Facilities Director
Facilities
Director 
Strategically manage commercial and residential portfolios onsite in US and Canada. Exe
...>MORE

Nursing
NURSING. ElderWood Senior Care, "Care Without Compromise". We invite you to stop by and learn how you can become part of...>MORE

Certified Pharmacy Tech's & Certified Medication Tech's
Certified Pharmacy Tech’s & Certified
Medication Tech’s Competitive wages. Call Lisa McKensie Ransomville Manor 79
...>MORE

See all ads

Feature Autos

Dodge 2001 Neon
Dodge 2001 Neon 4 dr, auto, a/c, new tires, c/d no rust, inspected, $3900. white 860-2854...>MORE

Buick 2005 Lesabre
BUICK 2005 Lesabre Custom, excellent condition, fully loaded, $6700 or best offer, 754-4540...>MORE

Chevy 2003 Impala
CHEVY 2003 Impala
25,600 miles, loaded
Exc. Cond. $10,000/bo
297-2199
...>MORE

Ford 1995 Crown Victoria
Ford 1995 Crown Victoria 4 dr, loaded, new tires must see & drive $3500. red. 860-2854...>MORE

VW 2001 Beetle
VW 2001 Beetle, loaded, GLX turbo, exc. cond, all service records, fun to drive, blue bk $5600, take best offer, 990-06...>MORE

Chevy 2007 Impala LT
CHEVY 2007 Impala LT
25,800 mi, ext. warranty
Exc. Cond, $16,500
297-2199
...>MORE

Mercury 1999 Grand Marquis
Mercury ‘99 Grand Marquis 4 dr, leather, all options, 49k org mi., showroom cond. $6000. 860-2854, ...>MORE

Mazda 1995 Millenia
Mazda 1995 Millenia loaded, leather, only 26k mi. exc. cond. $2995. Best Offer
531-3548, 297-1526
...>MORE

See all ads

See all ads


 

Community Newspaper Holdings, Inc.CNHI Classified Advertising NetworkCNHI News Service
Associated Press content © 2009. All rights reserved. AP content may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.
Our site is powered by Zope and our Internet Yellow Pages site is powered by PremierGuide.
Some parts of our site may require you to download the Flash Player Plugin.
View our Privacy Policy
Advertiser index