Toast and Roast: 4823 Saunders Settlement Rd, Niagara Falls
In my quest to try and hit as many eateries in Niagara County as I can, Donna, my wife, and Ed, my buddy, and I popped into the Toast and Roast for breakfast one Saturday. They have an ample parking lot and we had no trouble getting a place by the door. When we entered, I noticed how fresh and clean the place looked. They also had memes posted on all the walls.
This quaint little place is near the intersection of Military Road and Saunders Settlement Road. The atmosphere is homey and comfortable. The diner is very small, maybe 15 tables and a counter and they serve breakfast all day and lunch.
We grabbed a table by the door and Michele came over to take our drink order. Donna had water with lemon, Ed had his usual coffee ($2) and I opted for a Pepsi ($2.25).
They have a rather limited menu so it wasn’t hard to select our meal. When Michele came back, we told her we needed separate checks and she didn’t flinch. Sometimes it is a problem to get severs to separate the meals for you.
Donna ordered a No. 4, 2 eggs and toast and homefries ($5.95). When Michele asked how she wanted her eggs cooked, Donna told her poached and put them on the toast. Michele informed her they don’t do poached. Who doesn’t do poached? Michele said they could have them basted. We had never heard of “basted eggs” so Michele explained they cook it under a metal cover. She said it was like poached so Donna selected this way. Ed picked the No. 8. A bacon and cheese omelet with homefries (8.75). I picked a No. 4, 2 eggs, over easy, homefries and toast ($5.95).
Our meals arrived rather quickly and Michele even brought ketchup and hot sauce. The one thing I was missing was a “set up,” a placemat, napkin and silverware. She corrected this quickly and we all dug in to breakfast.
Ed pronounced his omelet delicious and said that it had a good amount of bacon in it. He also said his coffee was good. My eggs were fine but the homefries were definitely not homemade. They were like uniformly sized, short, fat French fries. I thought they even seemed deep fat fried and were a bit crisp for my liking. My toast was thicker than most but it was so lightly buttered that I could not tell which side the butter was on. There was plenty of grape jelly packets table side though. Grape jelly is my favorite. Donna’s basted eggs weren’t at all like poached eggs and her yolks weren’t soft, more like medium. Donna loves having runny yolks that she can soak up with her toast.
Like most small local diners, the staff and the customers seemed to know each other and engaged in small talk and chit chat. It looked like they had a number of regulars.
The bills arrived just as we were finishing our meal and when we looked at them we noticed neither the prices nor the totals were on them. They just listed what we had for breakfast. Off they went to get this error corrected. I joked with Michele saying that I thought maybe breakfast was free.
I give them 7 out of 10 spoons.
Open daily, Monday through Saturday 6:30 a.m. to 2 p.m. and Sunday 8 a.m. to 1 p.m.Takeout available.Phone: 297-4172Norb Rug is a writer from Lockport. His blog is WhyWNY.home.blog.